In the quiet folds of the Ozark Mountains, where the mist hangs low over the cornfields and every sound echoes across hollows and ridges, folks once told a story that every farmhand knew by heart, the story of how a man got caught “doing it with a bucket.”
The tale begins in a small mountain village, one of those close-knit places where gossip travels faster than a mule on market day. The men gathered most mornings at the general store, sitting on nail kegs, chewing tobacco, and swapping news. Among them was Elmer Pruitt, a wiry, talkative man known for having “a head full of sense, and none to spare.”
Discover ancient tales passed down by the Indigenous peoples of the Americas.
Elmer was not mean-spirited, but he was known to cut corners. Folks said he could borrow a tool so long that its owner forgot who it belonged to. He always had an excuse ready, a long-winded one at that, and somehow his tongue worked faster than his hands.
Now, just after a long, rainy spell, Farmer Rigsby’s lower pasture turned soft as pudding. His cows tramped through the mud, and his prized fence post started leaning. One morning, Rigsby discovered something odd, half a bucket stuck in the mud near his barn, and a trail of footprints leading straight to the Pruitt place.
“Looks like somebody’s been helping himself to my fertilizer,” Rigsby muttered. “And I reckon I know who.”
By sundown, the story had rolled through the village like thunder through the hills. At the general store that evening, Elmer was already there, acting innocent and laughing louder than anyone. But when the subject came up, his voice grew quick and high.
“Now hold on there!” he said, waving his arms. “I ain’t never took so much as a handful of that man’s fertilizer! Not me! Why, I been mindin’ my own business all week, patchin’ my roof and haulin’ water. Ain’t even set foot near his pasture. Matter of fact, I loaned my bucket to Cousin Lester!”
“Well,” said Old Man Craddock, squinting, “then how come Rigsby found your initials carved in that very same bucket?”
The men all turned to stare. Elmer coughed, scratched his neck, and stammered, “Well, see, that there’s a misunderstanding. I did own a bucket like that, sure enough, but it got itself misplaced months ago. You know how things wander off ‘round here.”
The more he talked, the deeper the hole he dug. By the next morning, the story had grown legs. Women whispering at the well said Elmer had been seen “haulin’ buckets by moonlight.” Children giggled and sang, “He done it with a bucket!” as they skipped stones in the creek.
At last, Rigsby decided to settle the matter. He and the preacher called a small gathering at the church yard, not quite a trial, but enough to clear the air. Elmer arrived red-faced and sweating, clutching his hat.
Rigsby held up the muddy bucket for all to see. “Elmer,” he said plainly, “this here bucket’s got your mark, your footprints, and your patch of shirt cloth caught on my fence post. Can you look us all in the eye and say you didn’t take that fertilizer?”
Elmer opened his mouth and shut it again. He shuffled his feet, glanced at the preacher, then said weakly, “Well… I might’ve borrowed a little, just to test my garden patch. Didn’t mean no harm by it.”
The preacher nodded solemnly. “Elmer, truth’s like water in a bucket, it’ll spill if you tip it too far. You’d best keep yours upright from now on.”
The crowd chuckled. Rigsby, being a fair man, told Elmer to work off the debt by mending his fences for a week, and that was that. But for years afterward, whenever someone tried to wriggle out of trouble, folks in the Ozarks would grin and say, “Careful now, or you’ll end up like Elmer, done it with a bucket!”
Immerse yourself in Latin America’s stories of passion, transformation, and spirit.
Moral Lesson
This Ozark folktale teaches lessons on truth and honesty. In small communities, one’s reputation is as fragile as a bucket’s handle, once broken, it’s hard to mend. It reminds us that a lie, no matter how small, often spills out in the end.
Knowledge Check
1. What region does “He Done It with a Bucket” come from?
It originates from the Ozark Mountains, a region covering parts of Arkansas and Missouri in the American South.
2. Who is the main character in this Ozark folktale?
Elmer Pruitt, a talkative farmer known for borrowing without asking and trying to cover his mistakes.
3. What object reveals the truth in the story?
A muddy bucket marked with Elmer’s initials, the key clue that exposes his dishonesty.
4. What moral does this Ozark folktale teach?
It teaches that honesty and truth are essential for maintaining trust and reputation in close-knit rural communities.
5. How is humor used in “He Done It With a Bucket”?
Humor softens the moral lesson, villagers laugh at Elmer’s blunders while still learning from his foolishness.
6. Why is the story significant in Ozark farm culture?
It reflects how Ozark communities valued accountability, reputation, and communal truth, all central to farm and village life.
Source: Ozark mountain folktale, collected by Vance Randolph in “Pissing in the Snow & Other Ozark Folktales” (University of Arkansas Folklore Archives).
Cultural Origin: United States (Ozark mountain folklore tradition, Arkansas–Missouri).
